Uncanny X-Men #11 - Marvel Comics

UNCANNY X-MEN No. 11, May 2025

As opening instalments go for a supposed "milestone X-Men crossover", Gail Simone’s narrative for “Echoes Of Madness” certainly seems to start out well with a shocking act of despicable treachery aboard the Shi’ar escort cruiser C’rylari by Navigator Elilan. But disappointingly, once poor Professor Xaiver is heavily sedated in his Graymalkin Prison cell, and his telepathic link to Xandra Neramani resultantly broken, this comic’s plot somewhat fatiguingly focuses upon (yet) another farmyard training session for the Outliers; “You go in the semicircle. And you stay on your feet. Three full minutes.” 

Admittedly, this sequence initially provides a bit of fun for the audience to enjoy as Nightcrawler quickly demonstrates to “little Calico” that the rookie mutant needs to always expect the unexpected, and the increasingly haughty Ransom taunts Wolverine over his 'old age'. However, the entire mood to so innocent-sounding a set-piece is suddenly turned upon its head by Rogue uncharacteristically commanding Gambit to take down one of the pupils “hard.” This bizarre order comes completely out of the blue, and is supposed to suggest that the team’s current leader is taking her responsibilities seriously.

Yet poor Sofia’s brush with a devastating kinetic energy-filled playing card probably just caused many a reader to scratch their heads in disbelief as to just how potentially injuring one of the X-Men’s proteges is apparently an example of strong governance. Indeed, at the very start of the exercise Jubilee even refers to the workout as being a “game”. So just why Anna Marie LeBeau gets all agitated as to the children’s playful attitude towards the challenge, and therefore questions whether they could survive a genuine threat to their existence, is a bit baffling – particularly as the quartet have literally just come back from besting a pack of killer Sentinel dogs at a local shopping precinct.

Furthermore, Remy’s smart-mouthed personality appears to have been completely sucked away by the American author, with the former Thieves Guild member acting more like a sycophant robot to his wife’s incongruous instructions, than the flamboyant, swashbuckling adventurer most fans will favour. Of particular note is how coldly he obeys Rogue’s directive to harm one of their wards, with artist Javier Garron pencilling the Cajun from New Orleans almost nonchalantly choosing his unsuspecting target, and then cold-heartedly flicking his deadly missile towards them without a trace of emotion upon his dead-pan face.

The regular cover art to "UNCANNY X-MEN" #11 by David Marquez & Matthew Wilson