BATMAN No. 33, September 2014 |
Whilst ending the creative team’s year-long retelling of
“the origin of the caped crusader” just as the title’s publisher “meant to
commemorate the character’s seventy-fifth anniversary” was undeniably “good
timing” on the part of Scott Snyder and “DC Comics”, it is doubtful that
all of this comic’s 117,996-strong readership either enjoyed or even understood
its narrative. Indeed the American author’s finale, which not only supposedly “sets
up who Batman is in the New 52 continuity” but also explains “the origin of the
Batcave’s giant penny and the Batarang”, arguably contains some of the most
outlandishly nonsensical writing since the Dark Knight donned a pair of
inter-galactic boxing gloves and solved “The Mystery Of The Outer Space
Olympics” in a 1958 issue of “Detective Comics”; “It is a pity you cannot
remain, friends. For your prowess has convinced us all that you could win the
Space Olympics!”
To begin with this final instalment of the “Savage City” story-arc’s
plot is based upon the illogical premise that the Riddler, despite believing
along with the rest of Gotham City that Batman is no more, has still gone to
the extreme lengths of constructing a “war of the mind” laser-beam death-trap
within his secret hideout which, if bested by his arch-nemesis in fourteen
minutes, will undo all of the super-villain’s long-laid plans. The creation of such
a device, and it’s reliance upon Nygma having to type in the answers when spoken,
simply makes no sense whatsoever except to contrivingly provide this book’s
titular character an opportunity to outwit Edward without “feats of physical
ferocity,… gizmos or gadgets.”
Equally as preposterous is the domino-mask wearing
criminal’s actual downfall, as the Riddler is ultimately defeated by
Lucius Fox strapping a giant penny on top of a transit van in order to
improvise a new “conductor to… [his] blocker”, rather than being outsmarted by
Bruce Wayne’s alter-ego. In fact Snyder incredibly has an even more ludicrous and
ignominious role for ‘his’ Batman to play, for in order to save Gotham City from
going “true black” the cowled vigilante must place an enormous electrode over
his heart and pass an almost certainly lethal thousand volt charge through his
body to reboot it!?!
Ultimately this comic frustratingly depicts the New Yorker’s “version
of Batman” and consolidates the writer’s “reimagining [of] his purpose… [and] his
formative years.” “Love it or hate it” this “Zero Year” incarnation sadly seems
a million miles away from the brave, steady and honourable cultural icon of Bob Kane and Bill Finger’s
co-creation. Certainly their (original) Caped Crusader would never have been “seconds
away” from undergoing electro-therapy in order “to be rebooted” and shocked “until
I wasn’t myself anymore” simply because they were having “more than a hard
time.”
The regular cover art of "BATMAN" No. 33 by Greg Capullo and Danny Miki |
I love reading your comic blog and almost without fail, I agree with your views. So well done on pulling no punches with this latest review. I've never been a big fan of Batman and this truly ludicrous series you've described has only reinforced my belief to stay well clear off the Caped Crusader. I was trying to remember if I'd ever bought a Batman comic in my life and at first thought I hadn't until I remembered I have the Batman/Judge Dredd graphic novel. Now that was worth buying! But Batman in his own series? No thanks! Sorry, mate!
ReplyDeleteBryan, many thanks indeed for your praise much appreciated. I'm really not sure just what Snyder was doing with this 12-issue series. presumably trying to make Batman his own the way Frank Miller managed with "The Dark Knight Returns". If so he has failed miserably imho. I'll be stopping this title once Capullo stops doing the art (imminently apparently). But that doesn't mean an end to my love of the Caped Crusader as there are a few mini-series etc I have lined up. Hopefully one of these will show what a good Batman story is all about... hopefully :-)
DeleteI am re-reading Batman by Snyder again (mainly for Court of Owls), but I think you hit squarely on his big weakness - not very much stands up to logical examination .
ReplyDeleteCheers PulpCitizen. This entire story-arc was an absolute stinker imho and I certainly won't be getting "Detective Comics" when Snyder takes over the helm following "DC Comics" alleged big reboot (again) over the summer.
Delete