MASTER OF KUNG FU No. 4, October 2015 |
Having endured this anti-climactic concluding instalment
to Shang-Chi’s “Secret Wars” mini-series, many readers will arguably wish that
writer Haden Blackmore had somehow managed to find a way “to pass up on an
opportunity to flesh out a new corner of the Marvel Universe”. For whilst his “Battleworld”
narrative is successful in “revolving around martial arts and the supernatural”,
the former “LucasArts” producer’s uninspiring final premise that the long-time enemies
of the Emperor’s “disgraced son” would actually aid him in his ‘mission’ to
become Zheng Zhu’s better, just because he admits he “sacrificed his honor” for
the sake of rival and former love Red Sai (Elektra), is implausible nonsense.
Certainly it is hard to imagine anyone who hates the true
“Master Of Kung Fu” as much as Daniel Rand-K’ai has been depicted doing
throughout this storyline, suddenly channelling their own life-force into their
arch-nemesis’ dying form just because the ailing combatant admits he “only
killed” Iron Fist’s Master to stop the Emperor from murdering an entire martial
arts school. As the unlikeable wielder of the mystical living force says
himself at the time of this unconvincing revelation “He should have found
another way. He could have killed his father instead…”
Dubious plotting and questionable motivations aside
however, the computer games “creative director” does arguably produce something
of a memorable confrontation between Shang-Chi and his parent within the final
third of this comic book. In fact for close to eight pages it is hard to
disassociate Blackmore’s new version of Jim Starlin’s co-creation from the old,
as the master of Wushu goes toe-to-toe with Zheng Zhu and uses all manner of fighting
techniques in order to eventually outwit the evil tyrant…
Admittedly Steve Englehart’s extraordinarily skilled warrior
from the Seventies never manifested unearthly magical proficiencies such as “the
power to harden my hands into the mortal blade” or “to force all of my most
painful memories into the mind of another…” But considering within this ‘alternative
universe’ martial artists are bestowed with “a wide range of powers and
abilities” like “intangibility and even shape-shifting”, such an extreme
variance to the original ‘powerless’ Shang-Chi is just about tolerable.
Perhaps slightly more bearable than the script to “Master
And Apprentice” is the action-packed artwork of Dalibor Talajic. The Croatian
penciller’s panels depicting Rand-K’ai and Red Sai’s all-too brief battle with this
comic’s “battered and exhausted” main protagonist is full of dynamic movement and
rather well-drawn. Unfortunately though the same cannot be said for the
illustrator’s portrayal of the Emperor’s ultimate battle with his son in the
Thirteenth Chamber, with parts of "the Final Battle", such as Shang-Chi’s
application of the “Lost Hope” technique upon his father’s brow, appearing
rather amateur-looking at best.
Writer: Haden Blackman, Penciler: Dalibor Talajic, and Inker: Goran Sudzuka |
What a disappointment. As I've told you before I'm a big fan of Shang Chi, but this is one series I have no intention of buying. I should thank you for your honest reviews, Simon. I'm pleased you pulled no punches in saying what you truly felt and you words rang true for me.
ReplyDeleteSorry I couldn't convince you to pick this one up Bryan, especially as I know of your love for "Master Of Kung Fu". However although I thought the mini-series was okay, and sadly one of the better "Secret Wars" titles currently being published by "Marvel Worldwide", I wouldn't buy it as a tpb myself. Its an interesting take on Shang-Chi, but not want Bronze Age fans want... Perhaps I should start dipping into my backlog of "Master Of Kung Fu" instead ;-)
Delete