Uncanny X-Men #5 - Marvel Comics

UNCANNY X-MEN No. 5, January 2025

Most certainly delivering a "brutal conclusion to the Red Wave storyline”, Gail Simone’s script for Issue Five of “Uncanny X-Men” probably had the vast majority of its readers holding their breath in anticipation of how a well-beaten Rogue was physically going to look once the Hag had finished scalping the unconscious mutant. However, such engrossment must surely have waivered once the American author suddenly reintroduces an already dead telepath known as Harvey X into the mix, and far too conveniently has the youth miraculously re-energise the fallen super-hero to the point where she instantly bests a monster who previously was comprehensively cleaning Anna Marie LeBeau’s clock.

In fact, this rather bizarre reversal in fortunes comes so completely out of the blue that some bibliophiles will doubtless feel that the Oregon-born writer so badly penned herself into a corner by having Chris Claremont’s co-creation fall unconscious, that all she could come up with was this unconvincing 'miracle' to get the former member of the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants back upon her feet; “I’ve got a bit of healing power, too. It kept me alive, you know.? Down to my last li’l bit. Been saving it for you.”

Similarly as dissatisfying is debatably the swift effect Rogue defeating Sarah Gaunt has upon the rest of the titular characters – who up until this point were quite literally on their last legs fighting off the Hag’s killer army. Just like LeBeau’s aforementioned confrontation, this last stand appeared to be going very badly for Gambit, Wolverine, Nightcrawler and Jubilee. But just as the protagonists are about to bravely fall before far superior numbers, the action cuts away from the battle and disappointingly doesn’t return until after Remy has supposedly just told their murderous assailants “to go home." - Something they apparently very obligingly do..!?!

Much more persuasive than this twenty-page periodical’s plot is David Marquez’s artwork, which does a tremendous job of showing just how seriously wounded Anna Marie actually is. Such trauma is really important to this comic’s storytelling as it greatly contrasts with the much more positive look upon the mutant’s face when Charlie X has restored her vitality, and the Hag is kicked into next week with a single, well-placed boot. Furthermore, there’s a palpable sense of desperation to be found in the pulse-pounding panels depicting the rest of the X-Men’s last stand, and this is predominantly down to the illustrator giving the leading cast some wonderfully dynamic poses.

The regular cover art to "UNCANNY X-MEN" #5 by David Marquez & Matthew Wilson